‘Knox Goes Away’ Evaluation — A Puzzling Misfire From Michael Keaton

This overview was initially a part of our protection for the 2023 Toronto Worldwide Movie Competition.

It’s protected to say that we live in a brand new period of hitman films from the John Wick franchise to David Fincher‘s The Killer, and Richard Linklater‘s Hit Man. On the small display, we have now Invoice Hader‘s unbelievable darkish comedy Barry, the place a hitman finds his calling within the LA performing scene. Let’s face it, when have not hitman films been cool? Positive, there have been these two crappy online game films starring Timothy Olyphant and Rupert Pal, and yeah there was that fairly dumb hitman romcom starring Sam Rockwell and Anna Kendrick, however past that, hitman tales are nice. Michael Keaton seemingly believes this as properly, as may be seen by his newest movie Knox Goes Away, his first directorial effort since The Merry Gentleman in 2008.

Knox Goes Away tells the story of John Knox (Keaton), an getting old hitman whose reminiscence is quickly failing him attributable to Creutzfeldt-Jakob illness, a type of dementia that strikes at a a lot sooner fee than traditional. Even with the analysis, John continues to be making an attempt to do his job to one of the best of his capability, however his reminiscence loss is continually getting in the best way. Fortunately, he finds his shot at redemption when his estranged son Miles Knox (James Marsden) exhibits up at his door pleading for his assist after killing the person who knocked up his teenage daughter. John is ready to cowl up the homicide, however his good intentions solely take him as far as his son quickly turns into wrapped up in his prison life as properly. John additionally brings in his previous buddy Xavier (Al Pacino) with a view to assist tie up free ends, particularly as his reminiscence is in a state of free fall.

No one Comes Out of ‘Knox Goes Away’ Unscathed

Keaton is undoubtedly a terrific actor as his distinctive charisma and distinct display presence have at all times been in a position to elevate the characters he performs. Since his Oscar-nominated efficiency in Birdman, he is accomplished an efficient job of with the ability to star in each status fare like Highlight and The Founder and extra business performs like Spider-Man: Homecoming and the underrated motion flick The Protégé. Hell, he arguably simply gave the strongest efficiency of his profession within the 2021 Hulu miniseries Dopesick for which he received his first Emmy. That is what makes his resolution to not solely star in but in addition to direct Knox Goes Away so rattling bizarre. There is a terrific lead efficiency inside Keaton for this explicit position, one the place he can take his on-screen presence in a unique route, enjoying a personality in a way more weak and fewer assured place. Nevertheless, whereas he is serviceable sufficient, one thing simply feels a bit of bit off and never in an intentional means both. Within the fingers of a filmmaker that he is had success with up to now like John Lee Hancock or Tom McCarthy, possibly his efficiency could have come throughout as extra plausible. It is not like Keaton is a nasty actor, he is a nationwide treasure. That is the person who performed each Batman and Beetlejuice only a yr other than one another. That is an actor with some critical vary, however he finally feels miscast right here.

Nevertheless, that is nothing in comparison with Marsden’s inclusion within the movie. Whereas there may very well be some recency bias from Jury Obligation, he’s nearly at all times a welcome presence in nearly each film and present that he pops up in. As for his work in Knox Goes Away, neither Keaton nor screenwriter Gregory Poirier fairly know what to do with him. Marsden’s character is meant to be fragile and unpredictable as he’s a person who killed somebody in an act of blind rage and is keen to embarrass his household by moving into altercations whereas making an attempt to have lunch at a diner. Marsden has performed smarmy roles earlier than like in Useless to Me and Anchorman 2. For as candy and real as he may be, he is additionally at all times been nice at enjoying an asshole. But in Knox Goes Away, it is extraordinarily onerous to purchase Marsden within the position he is given. His appeal is totally absent and it is simply painful to see in this sort of position. Pacino additionally pops in for a number of scenes as Xavier, and as entertaining as he’s in his position, the story by no means actually is aware of what it desires to do together with his character both.

‘Knox Goes Away’ Is Too Uninteresting To Ever Be Partaking

A hitman with reminiscence loss is such a inventive premise that might’ve led to an thrilling and interesting thriller. Hitmen in films are at all times introduced as characters who work with precision, and every part is deliberate out fastidiously. Throwing a monkey wrench in like dementia is a recent tackle the type of film that we’re used to seeing time and time once more. Keaton’s course simply feels too meandering and sluggish for the viewers to ever change into totally engaged with no matter is going on on display. There are a few sequences, notably because the movie reaches its conclusion, that present much more promise in Keaton’s filmmaking, with these scenes feeling efficient and thrilling, however they arrive far too late. At that time, the movie feels damaged past restore.

The movie simply by no means is aware of whether or not it desires to current itself as a neo-noir or a darkish comedy. It’s as if Michael Mann and the Coen Brothers teamed as much as make a film collectively, and whereas each are wonderful filmmakers in their very own proper, their methods of telling tales are far completely different. Knox Goes Away makes an attempt to have one of the best of each worlds however fails at each. It squanders far an excessive amount of of its potential to even warrant giving the movie a attempt. There’s an attention-grabbing story in right here, and a much better Keaton efficiency inside it too, however it’s the type of thriller that lacks the stress and pleasure that it wanted.

Knox Goes Away

REVIEW

Whereas Knox Goes Away boasts loads of proficient performers who’ve accomplished nice work elsewhere, none of them are in a position to salvage this bizarre misfire.

Knox Goes Away is now accessible to stream on VOD within the U.S.

WATCH ON VOD