The 2024 Oscars’ finest tune class, ranked : NPR

Clockwise from high left: Billie Eilish, Mark Ronson, Scott George, Diane Warren and Jon Batiste.

Getty Photographs

cover caption

toggle caption

Getty Photographs

Clockwise from high left: Billie Eilish, Mark Ronson, Scott George, Diane Warren and Jon Batiste.

Getty Photographs

Given the business and awards dominance of Barbie‘s soundtrack — which was, if you happen to keep in mind, the most-nominated album at this yr’s Grammys — you would be forgiven for pondering that this yr’s race for one of the best unique tune Oscar boils all the way down to Enjoyable Barbie (Ryan Gosling’s “I am Simply Ken”) vs. Pensive Barbie (Billie Eilish’s “What Was I Made For?”). However the area has much more going for it than that, from a stunning Jon Batiste ballad to a shifting piece by the Osage Tribal Singers to… properly, the umpteenth nomination for songwriter Diane Warren, and even that tune is not horrible!

That is the sixth yr I’ve ranked the nominated songs for NPR — here is 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020 and 2019 — and this is without doubt one of the higher fields throughout. So let’s tee ’em up, in ascending order of high quality.

5. “The Hearth Inside,” Flamin’ Sizzling, carried out by Becky G (Diane Warren, songwriter)

It is onerous to plan new methods to say {that a} Diane Warren composition will get nominated on this class each single yr, invariably on the expense of superior songs. She’s locked into an everlasting paradox: sufficient institutional assist for a seventh consecutive nomination (!!), by no means sufficient juice to win.

So right here we’re, but once more, pondering Doomed Nomination No. 15 and thanking our fortunate stars that “The Hearth Inside” is definitely… first rate, as recent-vintage Diane Warren songs go. Lyrically, it is simply one other slice of quasi-inspirational, nominally defiant boilerplate, dragged down by couplets that may trigger a generative AI program to resign in embarrassment (“They are going to suppose they will cease you / However there is no stopping you”). Rise, stand, combat, you bought this, they cannot maintain you again, blah blah blah, severely, have ChatGPT and Diane Warren ever been seen in the identical room collectively?

Musically, “The Hearth Inside” is an effervescent and totally inoffensive trifle, introduced residence by a charismatic vocal from Becky G. As an entire, that is in all probability Warren’s finest Oscar-nominated tune since 2015’s “Til It Occurs to You” (a Girl Gaga collaboration that ought to have overwhelmed Sam Smith’s “Writing’s on the Wall”), which is no less than saying one thing. Simply, , not a lot. Had Flamin’ Sizzling by no means existed — and the way unhappy it will have been for the world to be denied Eva Longoria’s sub-featherweight brand-fluffing biopic! — Warren would have simply gotten nominated for “Gonna Be You” from 80 for Brady.

4. “Wahzhazhe (A Tune for My Individuals),” Killers of the Flower Moon, carried out by Osage Tribal Singers (Scott George, songwriter)

Possibly I am using excessive on the joys of not having to put in writing about Diane Warren for an additional 12 months, however it is a robust area! Subsequent up is “Wahzhazhe (A Tune for My Individuals),” which closes Martin Scorsese’s epic Killers of the Flower Moon — and pointedly offers the Osage Nation the final phrase. An unconventional entry in a area usually reserved for English-language songs by well-known artists, “Wahzhazhe” had an uncommon variety of hurdles to clear with a view to get nominated, beginning with the truth that it had by no means been written down previous to submission.

The primary Native American nominated for finest unique tune, songwriter Scott George crafted a rousing work that transcends its place in a film’s closing credit: It is a work of celebration that fits its second within the movie whereas chatting with the Osage Nation’s resilience within the face of systemic discrimination and homicide. And it will certainly sound terrific when carried out on Oscar night time, which is simply another reason amongst many to cheer its inclusion.

3. “It By no means Went Away,” American Symphony, carried out by Jon Batiste (Jon Batiste and Dan Wilson, songwriters)

American Symphony paperwork 2021 Oscar winner Jon Batiste’s efforts to put in writing a symphony whereas his spouse, bestselling writer Suleika Jaouad, battled leukemia. As documentaries go, it is shifting with out being terribly revealing — which may also be mentioned for the Oscar-nominated ballad that performs over the movie’s closing credit. However the attractive piano line that propels “It By no means Went Away” positive does hit onerous, as Batiste serenades his spouse in a lullaby of devotion.

Not like so many Oscar-nominated closing-credits songs earlier than it, “It By no means Went Away” feels richly related to the themes of the film previous it. The phrases Batiste sings aren’t precisely novel — “Thought I used to be a smart lad / Whenever you plan, God laughs” — however the tune as an entire fantastically captures the expertise of affection as an accumulation of hard-won moments, cast in shared sacrifice.

2. “I am Simply Ken,” Barbie, carried out by Ryan Gosling (Mark Ronson and Andrew Wyatt, songwriters)

It is just about inconceivable to decide on which eligible Barbie tune most deserves this yr’s Oscar: You could possibly make a powerful case for each nominated songs, in addition to Dua Lipa’s effervescent “Dance the Night time,” which was shortlisted however missed the minimize. (Lately, Oscar guidelines stipulate that not more than two songs will be nominated from a single movie.)

So, severely, consider Ryan Gosling’s wild, joke-dense “I am Simply Ken” as No. 1a greater than No. 2 — although it does appear becoming that poor Ken could be relegated to second place but once more. Half inspirational battle anthem, half dream ballet, half ’80s power-ballad pastiche, “I am Simply Ken” soundtracks one among Barbie‘s many key scenes, advancing the plot even because it dispenses catchphrases (“Can you’re feeling the Kenergy?”) and asks the questions so many people have requested of ourselves (“Am I not scorching once I’m in my emotions?”).

Although “What Was I Made For?” stays this yr’s seemingly winner, it would not be an enormous shock if “I am Simply Ken” had been to stand up and snatch the Oscar from its extra somber Barbie counterpart. The tune pulls off a genuinely superior feat: a grand and intelligent piece of comedic spectacle that’s, amongst different superlatives, nice at doing stuff. And, if you happen to’re not grateful for “I am Simply Ken” now, simply wait till it reveals as much as enliven a three-and-a-half-hour Oscars telecast.

1. “What Was I Made For?,” Barbie, carried out by Billie Eilish (Billie Eilish and Finneas O’Connell, songwriters)

I am by no means going to fault anybody for selecting jokes over emotions, so that you’re greater than forgiven if you happen to favor “I am Simply Ken” to “What Was I Made For?” However, man, it is a attractive tune: melodically wealthy, a radiant vocal efficiency from Billie Eilish, a compelling technique to amplify the pathos in Barbie‘s story of self-awakening, and an precise chart hit in addition.

It is price noting as soon as once more how usually the Oscars’ finest unique tune area will get dominated by songs that roll harmlessly over closing credit — and, extra to the purpose, that fail to convey or mirror on what their movies had been attempting to say. This season, solely the Diane Warren tune actually falls brief in that regard; although they play over their respective credit, “Wahzhazhe (A Tune for My Individuals)” may solely come from Killers of the Flower Moon and “It By no means Went Away” may solely come from American Symphony. That is a giant step up from most years, which says nothing of how integral “I am Simply Ken” and “What Was I Made For?” are to Barbie.

Final yr’s Oscar area produced among the best and most satisfying winners this class has ever produced in “Naatu Naatu” from RRR. So long as Barbie will get its due this time round, we’re in for an additional all-timer.