[ad_1]
Jonathan Glazer‘s searing Oscars acceptance speech, by which The Zone of Curiosity filmmaker referenced the continued Israel-Gaza battle and stated that he refuted his “Jewishness and the Holocaust being hijacked by an occupation” has led to a fierce response on social media.
In his pre-prepared speech accepting the 2024 Academy Award for greatest worldwide movie, Glazer thanked his companions on The Zone of Curiosity, a haunting movie about Auschwitz and the Holocaust, after which made an announcement addressing each his work and a reference to the continued Israel-Gaza battle. “All our decisions have been made to mirror and confront us within the current, to not say, ‘look what they did then’; fairly, ‘what we do now,’” Glazer stated. “Our movie exhibits the place dehumanization leads at its worst. It’s formed all of our previous and current.”
Glazer, who’s Jewish, added: “Proper now, we stand right here as males who refute their Jewishness and the Holocaust being hijacked by an occupation which has led to battle for therefore many harmless individuals,” Glazer stated, pausing briefly on account of applause.
He continued, “Whether or not the victims of October seventh in Israel or the continued assault on Gaza, all of the victims of this dehumanization, how can we resist?”
Glazer then devoted the movie’s win to Alexandria, a 90-year-old girl he met whereas engaged on the movie and who impressed one of many key characters in The Zone of Curiosity.
The response to Glazer’s speech was swift, though a lot of the early detrimental sentiment occurred as some information websites hadn’t totally quoted the British filmmaker, or as a result of his quotes have been taken out of context with the remainder of his speech. Some individuals, incorrectly, took Glazer’s speech to imply that he was refuting his Jewishness, fairly than that he was refuting his “Jewishness and the Holocaust being hijacked by an occupation which has led to battle for therefore many harmless individuals,” as he stated in his speech.
MSNBC host Chris Hayes was fast to right individuals who have been misquoting Glazer. “I’m seeing [several] individuals saying this about Glazer’s speech, and it’s clearly improper,” Hayes tweeted together with the complete quote from Glazer.
“It was [a] little awkwardly phrased, however he’s clearly saying he refutes his Jewishness being hijacked. Not refuting his Jewishness,” added Hayes in a follow-up tweet.
Nonetheless, a number of outstanding Israeli and Jewish customers on X slammed Glazer for his feedback. Michael Freund, an Israeli political activist who served as a deputy director of communications below Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu within the Nineties, wrote on X, “Jonathan Glazer is a self-hating Jew of the worst type who exploits the Holocaust to assault Israel in public on the Oscars ceremony.”
Newsweek opinion columnist Batya Ungar-Sargon, one other who incorrectly quoted Glazer, wrote on X, “I merely can not fathom the ethical rot in somebody’s soul that leads them to win an award for a film in regards to the Holocaust and with the platform given to them, to just accept that award by saying, “We stand right here as males who refute their Jewishness.”
Amongst a flood of quote tweets and replies to Ungar-Sargon, Yonah Lieberman, the co-founder of IfNotNow, an American Jewish group that opposes the Israeli occupation of the West Financial institution and Gaza Strip, wrote on X, “You’re mendacity about what they stated by including a interval in the midst of their sentence. They clearly meant they refute the way in which their Jewishness has been hijacked. You’re alleged to be a journalist.”
Lieberman tweeted on Tuesday, “Virtually all these twisting Glazer’s phrases are Jewish themselves. Are you able to think about one other minority group so prepared to lie about considered one of their very own in an effort to uphold a established order the place an ethnostate can kill ladies and youngsters with impunity?”
Abraham Foxman, a director emeritus on the Anti-Defamation League, tweeted, “I’m happy that Zone of Curiosity was received one of the best worldwide movie on the Oscars – however as a survivor of the Holocaust I’m shocked the director would slap the reminiscence of over 1 million Jews who died as a result of they have been Jews by saying he refutes his Jewishness. Disgrace on you.” Foxman’s tweet, nevertheless, was slapped with a Neighborhood Observe for taking Glazer’s quote out of context.
Equally, conservative journalist John Podhoretz took Glazer’s feedback out of context. “By saying he refutes his Jewishness on the largest stage on this planet 5 months after the assault on Israel, Jonathan Glazer has immediately made himself into considered one of Judaism’s historic villains,” Podhoretz, the editor of Commentary, tweeted.
Additionally on Tuesday morning, conservative commentator Ben Shapiro, a staunch supporter of Israel’s army marketing campaign in Gaza, wasted no time in attacking Glazer, writing on X, “In Jonathan Glazer’s Zone of Curiosity, you don’t see one Jew. These are one of the best Jews, in keeping with Glazer: the faceless victims screaming within the distance. Paradoxically, he’s the villain: selecting up awards from the our bodies of these nameless useless Jews whereas ignoring the dwelling ones getting slaughtered within the Gaza Envelope by genocidal murderers.”
Glazer did obtain some assist from fellow Hollywood filmmakers. Jewish-American filmmaker Boots Riley was amongst Glazer’s outstanding friends who tweeted his assist on Sunday evening. “Salute to Jonathan Glazer. Not only for talking out in opposition to the atrocities in Gaza & saying that his film is in regards to the current day- however I lastly noticed Zone Of Curiosity final evening. Since Below The Pores and skin he has proven that you shouldn’t wait [till] put up to determine sound design.”
[ad_2]
